A critical review is an academic appraisal of an article that offers both a summary and critical comment. They are useful in evaluating the relevance of a source to your academic needs. They demonstrate that you have understood the text and that you can analyze the main arguments or findings. It is not just a summary; it is an evaluation of what the author has said on a topic. It’s critical in that you thoughtfully consider the validity and accuracy of the author’s claims and that you identify other valid points of view.
An effective critical review has three parts:
Steps to Write a Critical Review:
Q. What were the authors investigating? What is their thesis?
Q. What did the authors hope to discover?
D. Pay close attention to the methods used by the authors to collection information.
Q. What are the characteristics of the participants? (e.g.) Age/gender/ethnicity
Q. What was the procedure or experimental method/surveys used?
Q. Are their any flaws in the design of their study?
E. Review the main findings in the “Discussion” or “Conclusion” section. This will help you to evaluate the validity of their evidence, and the credibility of the authors.
Q. Are their conclusions convincing?
Q. Were their results significant? If so, describe how they were significant.
F. Evaluate the usefulness of the text to YOU in the context of your own research.
Q. How does this article assist you in your research?
Q. How does it enhance your understanding of this issue?
Q. What gaps in your research does it fill?
Good Summary:
Hock, S., & Rochford, R. A. (2010). A letter-writing campaign: linking academic success and civic engagement. Journal of Community Engagement and Scholarship, 3(2), 76-82.
Hock & Rochford (2010) describe how two classes of developmental writing students were engaged in a service-learning project to support the preservation of an on-campus historical site. The goal of the assignment was to help students to see how they have influence in their community by acting as engaged citizens, and to improve their scores on the ACT Writing Sample Assessment (WSA) exam. The authors report that students in developmental classes often feel disempowered, especially when English is not their first language. This assignment not only assisted them in elevating their written communication skills, but it also gave real-life significance to the assignment, and by extension made them feel like empowered members of the community. The advancement in student scores serves as evidence to support my research that when students are given assignments which permit local advocacy and active participation, their academic performance also improves.
Bad Summary:
Hock, S., & Rochford, R. A. (2010). A letter-writing campaign: linking academic success and civic engagement. Journal of Community Engagement and Scholarship, 3(2), 76-82.
Two ELL classes complete a service-learning project and improve their writing scores. This article was good because it provided me with lots of information I can use. The students learned a lot in their service-learning project and they passed the ACT exam.
Remember you're describing what someone else has said. Use verbal cues to make this clear to your reader. Here are some suggested verbs to use:
The article
|
The author
|
The researchers
|
* Adapted from: http://www.laspositascollege.edu/raw/summaries.php